NFTs Enter the Art Market
On 25 March 2021, an artwork created by the humanoid robot Sophia together with digital artist Andrea Bonaceto was auctioned for $688,888 in the form of a non-fungible token (NFT). In early March, Christie’s sold a collection of 5,000 digital artworks created by digital artist Beeple as an NFT for almost $70 million.
Although they have only recently come into the spotlight, NFTs have been around for a while, and at the end of 2017, they even slowed down the Ethereum blockchain because of the CryptoKitties craze.
The questions regarding the artistic value of such creations and whether these massive investments are nothing more than a bubble or the beginning of a new long-term way for artists to monetize their creations are interesting from both an artistic and an economic perspective. In this article, we focus on the legal considerations associated with NFT works.
What is an NFT?
An NFT is a unique cryptographic asset linked to a physical or digital work. It is blockchain-based and allows you to certify the authenticity of the associated work.
They are “non-fungible” because of their—at least theoretically—unique characteristics. In contrast, fungible things are traditionally defined as being easily replaced by a substitute item; the classic example is two liters of water that can be replaced by two other liters without any difference for the owner of that water.
In short, an NFT is both a digital certificate of authenticity of the (digital) work with which it is associated and stored in the blockchain, as well as a new option for creators to share new types of artwork.
Copyright and Ownership Rights
As with any contract relating to a copyrighted object, the creator and buyer can agree on the scope of the rights transferred. In any case, under Swiss law, some core elements of author’s moral rights always remain with the creator of the work and cannot be transferred. Such author’s moral rights include in particular the right to be named as the author and the right to decide on the date and manner of first publication of the work.
With respect to NFTs, we must distinguish between the NFT itself and the underlying work. While the underlying work will likely be protected by copyright as a digital or physical artwork, it is unlikely that the NFT itself will be protected by copyright. In fact, from a pragmatic perspective, an NFT is nothing more than a ledger and a link to the underlying work. As such, it will not meet the requirement of originality and is therefore not a copyrighted work under Swiss law.
Unless otherwise agreed, the author retains ownership of the underlying work, while the buyer is granted ownership of the NFT. The buyer is thus “only” entitled to claim the NFT and exclude others from it.
The consequence of this distinction between ownership of the NFT and copyright of the underlying work is that the owner of the NFT does not automatically have the right to reproduce the underlying work, create derivative works, or perform, display, or distribute the work.
However, the creator and buyer may also agree to transfer ownership of the underlying work along with the transfer of an NFT. The recent auction of a Basquiat drawing provides an example of a case where the buyer is given the option to destroy the original drawing, leaving the NFT as the only remaining form of Basquiat’s drawing. In any case, and as with traditional copyright transfer under Swiss law, the core of the work’s author’s moral rights must be preserved.
Finally, an NFT is nothing more than a digital receipt for the transfer of rights to a particular version of the underlying work, and like any kind of transfer of rights, its scope can be negotiated.
Licensing NFTs
The simplest way to address IP issues associated with NFTs is currently to create and distribute an NFT license. Such an approach has been pursued by, for example, CryptoKitties and NBA Top Shot, and ensures that buyers are clearly communicated the difference between acquiring a copyright and acquiring a right to use an object, namely a license.
The platforms NBA Top Shot and CryptoKitties are the two most widely used decentralized applications worldwide and generate an impressive revenue of $540 million (500 million for NBA Top Shot and 40 million for CryptoKitties). Both platforms offer examples of license agreements that allow users to purchase NFTs relating to digital cards of the best moments in the NBA or (of course) digital cats.
Both platforms are operated by Dapper Labs, which created an open-source license agreement related to the use of the ERC-721 standard for NFTs. The agreement includes the following principles:
- Ownership: The buyer agrees that the creator of the NFT owns all legal rights associated with the NFT and that only the rights expressly listed in the license agreement are transferred to the buyer.
- License: The buyer receives a worldwide, non-exclusive, non-transferable license to use, copy, or display the underlying object for personal use or commercial use, provided that such commercial use does not result in the buyer earning more than $100,000 per year. If earnings exceed this amount, the buyer must contact the creator to request a broader license agreement or an exception to the limitation.
- Restrictions: The buyer is also prohibited from modifying the underlying work in any way or using, promoting, or selling third-party objects without the creator’s consent.
The CryptoKitties terms detail the principles mentioned above but retain the $100,000 exception. Meanwhile, the NBA Top Shot platform is more restrictive and grants only a license for personal use, while prohibiting any commercial use without platform consent.
These are just examples. It is also possible to grant exclusive licenses. For instance, Daniel Arsham, a New York-based artist, recently published a digital sculpture as an NFT that evolves over time and depending on weather conditions. This sculpture was released as an exclusive work, with nine additional similar works to follow. Although the specific terms of the license agreement are not made public, it demonstrates the possibility of creating and selling exclusive NFTs similar to individual physical artworks.
Generally, the critical point for both buyers and creators is that the scope of their respective rights is clearly defined and that a mechanism is agreed upon to enable the payment of potential royalties. As we have seen, a license agreement serves this purpose and could be part of the platform’s terms. A smart contract using a specific token standard could be an alternative solution. In fact, the ERC-1190 standard is designed as an NFT for the payment of royalties and allows the creator of the underlying work to automatically benefit from any use of the work and receive the corresponding royalties. Without going into technical details, ERC-1190 allows the creator to retain creative license while selling the ownership license of the work and therefore continue to be entitled to a percentage of any profit the holder of the ownership license makes, whether through sale or rental of the underlying work.
Further Legal Implications of NFTs and Future Outlook
Numerous legal questions regarding NFTs will need to be answered, and these relate not only to intellectual property. As with any new technology, consumer protection issues will arise here as well, since the consumer must understand the rights associated with the acquired NFT. Tax considerations, both from an income tax and sales tax perspective, must also be taken into account. These are all points that must be carefully researched and incorporated into an NFT license agreement.
Furthermore, the use of NFTs in the future could also contribute to more secure intellectual property protection. Indeed, IBM in cooperation with IPwe announced that it will represent valuable patents as NFTs. This is intended to enable easier and more secure sales of patents and create new opportunities for fractionalizing patent ownership and licensing. According to the IPwe founder, such solutions could unlock a $1 trillion market for innovators, investors, and even SMEs.